The community of Metcalfe Park in Milwaukee is facing a major disruption as the beloved Pick n’ Save grocery store prepares to close its doors for good. After years of serving the neighborhood, the last remaining grocery store in the area will shut down on July 18, 2025.
The closure has left residents fearing the emergence of a “food desert,” where access to fresh food will become a significant challenge.
The Impact of the Closure
Pick n’ Save has been a staple in Wisconsin since 1975, with 82 locations across the state. The store at 2355 North 35th Street in Metcalfe Park, one of the few remaining grocery options for local residents, will close its doors permanently this week.
The news has been met with shock and disappointment from loyal customers who had no prior indication that the store was shutting down. Michael Davis, a frequent shopper, was stunned to learn about the closure, stating that there had been no signs or announcements prior to the final day.
The situation is particularly dire for those who rely on walking to the store, as the nearest alternative is located three miles away. For those without cars, this means either a long walk or a 30-minute bus ride, making it increasingly difficult for residents to access essential groceries.
Community Response and Rally
The closure has led to significant unrest among local residents, who have expressed frustration over the inconvenience and potential long-term effects on the neighborhood. Many voiced concerns about the lack of affordable food options nearby.
Earline Mannery, another Metcalfe Park resident, called the closure “tragic,” explaining that it would force people like herself to travel further for groceries.
In response to the closure, community members gathered for a rally outside the Pick n’ Save on the morning of July 18. The rally was organized by Metcalfe Park Community Bridges, with Melody McCurtis, the deputy director, leading the protest.
McCurtis emphasized that the closure should not happen quietly, urging the community to stand up for their rights and demand better access to local services.
Kroger’s Decision to Close Stores
Pick n’ Save, which was originally a local supermarket chain owned by Roundy’s, was acquired by Kroger in 2015. This closure is part of a larger trend, as Kroger has announced plans to shut down 60 underperforming stores over the next 18 months.
Although it is unclear whether the Metcalfe Park location is part of this list, the company has faced increased scrutiny for its decisions.
Kroger’s interim CEO, Ronald Sargent, addressed the closures during a recent conference call, explaining that the company is focused on making its operations more efficient.
While these closures will affect several areas, Kroger has also committed to opening at least 30 new stores in the coming months.
Sargent emphasized that these new store openings are a major focus for the company, as they aim to gain market share and strengthen their presence in various regions.
The Broader Impact of Store Closures
Kroger’s decision to close several locations is part of the company’s strategy to streamline its operations, but it has significant consequences for local communities, especially those that rely on the stores for everyday essentials.
The closure of Pick n’ Save in Metcalfe Park underscores the growing issue of “food deserts,” where entire neighborhoods lack access to fresh, affordable food. For residents in this area, the closure is not just an inconvenience—it is a barrier to maintaining a healthy lifestyle.
Additionally, the loss of a community-based grocery store can have a ripple effect on other local businesses. As more stores close and fewer people have access to convenient shopping options, the economic stability of neighborhoods can be compromised.
Source
